Feeds:
Posts
Comments

Posts Tagged ‘speakeasy’

ImageEvery once in awhile, I review a book for Speakeasy.  The description for this book intrigued me, “Cross Examined challenges the popular intellectual arguments for Christianity and invites the reader to shore them up  …….. or discard them.  Take the journey and see where it leads you.”

Enticing for sure.  And the book does what is promised – it definitely challenges some intellectual arguments for Christianity.  But Ican’t say I recommend it, for several reasons.

First, it’s an apologetics text masquerading as a novel.  The writing is fair if not eloquent, but the story is pretty simple and the long stretches where the story is interrupted for teaching are awkward.  Second, the biased nature of the story is not helpful.  The atheist is good.  The Christian pastor is bad.  The Christian parents are old-fashioned tyrants.  The Buddhists are nice.  There is no nuance, every character is fairly one-sided.

Finally, I find the apologetics to be tiring.  Full disclosure, I am a Christian and a minister.  But the intellectual debate around Christianity has never held much sway for me.  I’m not interested in proving my faith, I’m interested in living it.  There is enough in following Jesus, trying to love as he loved and proclaiming resurrection – light in the midst of darkness for me.  Arguing philosophical points doesn’t make or break my faith.

Maybe this book is for others for whom these arguments are energizing.  I had hoped that the novel would help to make the process less annoying for me.  Unfortunately, I did not find that to be the case.

http://www.patheos.com/blogs/crossexamined/

Beloved

Advertisements

Read Full Post »